Carnivore Diet Reddit: The Most Common Questions Answered (With the Science)

The carnivore diet communities on Reddit -- particularly r/carnivore and r/zerocarb -- are among the most active dietary communities on the platform. The same questions appear repeatedly from new practitioners, and the community has developed nuanced, experience-based answers over years of collective practice. Here are the most frequently asked questions with the community consensus and the scientific context behind each.

Q: I am on day 3 and feel terrible. Is this normal? Yes. The adaptation phase peaks around days 3-5. Fatigue, headaches, brain fog, and digestive disruption are normal signs the metabolic switch is happening. Increase salt, drink bone broth, and push through. Most people feel significantly different by day 7-10.

Q: How much should I eat? Eat to satiety. The community answer and the research-backed answer are the same. Protein and fat satiety hormones make overeating structurally difficult once adapted. If you are hungry, eat more. Do not restrict.

Q: Do I need to track macros? Most experienced practitioners say no. The 80/20 fat-to-protein ratio emerges naturally from choosing fatty cuts and eating to satiety. Tracking is useful for the first 30 days to confirm you are eating enough fat. Most practitioners stop after month one.

Q: My cholesterol went up. Should I be worried? The cholesterol response to carnivore varies between individuals. LDL often rises initially. HDL typically rises as well. Triglycerides typically fall significantly. The triglyceride-to-HDL ratio -- a more meaningful metabolic health marker -- typically improves substantially on carnivore. The traditional LDL-focused cardiovascular risk model does not straightforwardly apply to carnivore practitioners.

Q: What skincare can I use on carnivore? The community's consistent finding: if you are eliminating seed oils from your diet for the reasons carnivore advocates for, applying seed oil-based moisturizer to your face is a logical contradiction. The Opulent Facial Elixir -- wagyu tallow, organic olive oil, lavender essential oil -- is the skincare product most aligned with carnivore principles.

Q: How long until I see results? 30 days for adaptation completion. 60 days for clear before-and-after differences. 90 days for the new baseline. The most common reason for not seeing results is stopping before the adaptation is complete.

--

The carnivore Reddit community is massive, and Fomo21 has built apparel for the people in it who have committed to more than just a dietary experiment -- fomo21.com/collections/carnivore.

Shop the full Golden Tallow lineup at goldentallow.com. 🤍